78%
15%
4%
1%
1%
Highlights
This elegant family-owned BYOB restaurant serves refined Italian dishes like grilled branzino with balsamic reduction and seafood fettuccine
Customer Reviews
100% Verified Reviews
All reviews are from people who have redeemed deals with this merchant.food
service
staff
atmosphere
ambiance
meal
byob
dinner
experience
portions
price
waiter
entrees
appetizer
desserts
dishes
menu
decor
calamari
chicken
Daletop reviewer shutterbug
44 ratings29 reviews5 photos
The waiter was awesome. The food was
Just second
Petertop reviewer
45 ratings31 reviews
Not our first visit to Cara Mia and we're never disappointed. Not only is everything delicious but they will alter the meal to suit your tastes.
Always great service and pleasant surroundings.
Anthony
6 ratings3 reviews
The service was flawless. They had specials which is very welcome especially since we've been here many times and look for something new. Quality of food is 5 stars. Menu is diverse but could use some more seafood, however there is always a seafood special (we went on a Sunday)
Andrea
2 ratings2 reviews
We have been coming to Cara Mia for years. The food is always fabulous and the staff is very friendly and attentive.
Kin
4 ratings2 reviews
I never expected the food and the service would be so great. I hope more people get to know this restaurant, Cara Mia！
Mariposatop reviewer
20 ratings18 reviews
The food is succulent. Staff is friendly and courteous. The ambiance is cozy.
Customer Photos
Report Photo
Report Photo
Helpful
Error submitting request
Thank you for your response
Customer Photos
About This Deal
- Type of food: Italian
- Valid for dinner on the listed days
- View the menu and prices
#####Cara Mia’s COVID-19 Precautions
- The restaurant is open for indoor dining, outdoor dining, and takeout.
- Clients can call ahead to place their orders.
- Note that state and local guidelines are changing regularly. Please check Cara Mia’s website or contact them for their latest guidelines.
Fine Print
Promotional value expires 120 days after purchase. Amount paid never expires.
Not valid on federal holidays. Not valid on Valentine's Day. Not valid on Easter. Not valid on Mother's Day. Not valid on Father's Day. Not valid on Christmas Eve. Not valid on New Year's Eve. Reservation recommended, especially for Sundays. Not valid with any other offers or promotions. Not valid for cash back. Not valid on St. Patrick's Day and 4th of July. Dinner option valid only Sunday-Thursday. Valid only at 194 Essex Street in Millburn, NJ 07041. Valid for dine-in only; guests may request takeout due to present circumstances but must pay a 20% staff gratuity. Limit 4 per person. May be repurchased every 365 days. Limit 1 per visit. Limit 1 per table.
Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.
About Cara Mia
With its exposed-brick walls, white tablecloths, and rustic artwork, Cara Mia is the portrait of an elegant, intimate restaurant. Surrounded by this welcoming ambiance, the BYOB family-owned spot provides diners with a menu of classic Italian cuisine prepared with only the freshest and finest ingredients. Read on to learn about a few of the standout dishes.
- Appetizer: homemade veal and beef meatballs smothered in a tomato-based sauce and garnished with fresh ricotta cheese and basil
- Salad: endive leaves tossed with bosc pears, gorgonzola, and toasted walnuts and drizzled with white-balsamic vinaigrette
- Pasta: jumbo lump crab meat, shrimp, shallots, diced tomatoes, and roasted peppers sit atop a bed of fettuccine finished with a sauce of white wine and cream and garnished with garlic and chili flakes
- Entree: grilled branzino topped with asparagus, portobello mushrooms, and zucchini and served in a light balsamic reduction
- Dessert: creamy homemade ricotta cheesecake garnished with confectioner's sugar, fresh strawberries, and whipped cream