Coney Island Pizza, RiverdaleConey Island Pizza, Riverdale

Coney Island Pizza, Riverdale4.89
290 reviews
This merchant doesn't have any deals and is not affiliated with Groupon. Please contact them directly for services.

About Coney Island Pizza

Before settling into Coney Island Pizza, the eatery's dough-spinners manned Coney Island Catering, a mobile wood-fired oven that supplied pies for soirees and corporate functions. The team and its tools still hit the road for catering assignments and special events. For the most part, however, the oven remains in house, where it bakes specialty pizzas crowned with roasted clams, pulled pork, and pistachios.

Besides pies, the oven roasts other bistro and pizzeria eats, from organic farm-raised Scottish salmon to hot wings tossed in sriracha lime sauce. Complemented exclusively with wines from the award-winning Ventimiglia Vineyard, feasts can end on sweet notes with housemade desserts, including seasonal cannoli filled with autumnal pumpkin or wintry snowballs.

Recommended For You

Nearby Places

    Pat's Pizzeria

    Pat's Pizzeria

    Hillcrest(0.73 mi)
    Thatcher McGhee's

    Thatcher McGhee's

    Hillcrest(0.72 mi)
    Monicas Italian Restaurant

    Monicas Italian Restaurant

    Pompton Lakes(0.79 mi)
    Tony's Pizza

    Tony's Pizza

    Hillcrest(0.63 mi)
    Karen's Country Kitchen

    Karen's Country Kitchen

    Hillcrest(0.04 mi)
    Mack's American Bar & Grill

    Mack's American Bar & Grill

    Hillcrest(0.62 mi)
    Franks Pizza of Pompton Lakes

    Franks Pizza of Pompton Lakes

    West Knoll(0.78 mi)
    Blimpie

    Blimpie

    Hillcrest(0.13 mi)
    Pompton Lakes Diner

    Pompton Lakes Diner

    Hillcrest(0.65 mi)

Groupon Customer Reviews

4.89
290 Groupon Ratings
100% Verified Reviews

All Groupon reviews are from people who have redeemed deals with this merchant. Review requests are sent by email to customers who purchased the deal.

J
Janine
16 Ratings
9 Reviews
· 9 years ago
Food was amazing I will definitely go back we love the pizza and the meatball sliders for an appetizer were delicious .. An apple pie is a must try .
S
Steven
11 Ratings
11 Reviews
· 9 years ago
All of the food is excellent, the service is great and you get a friendly greeting from the wait staff and the chefs when you arrive and when you leave. They seem to be genuinely concerned that you enjoyed yourself.
A
Amy
47 Ratings
10 Reviews
· 9 years ago
The food was all delicious! Tried the meatball sliders, truffle shuffle pie and the banana nutella dessert pie. All were excellent, but the dessert pie was out of this world. Staff was very friendly & service was great. We will be back.
L
Lena
3 Ratings
1 Reviews
· 9 years ago
Get the pulled pork pizza and banana nutella pizza!! You won't regret it!!
A
Anita
35 Ratings
11 Reviews
· 9 years ago
Even though there was about a 30 minute wait, we would go back. We also wanted the wings, but they were sold out. Meatball sliders were tasty and all the pizzas were great. The apple and nutella dessert was the best! Marissa was very attentive to our table...
C
cheryl
15 Ratings
13 Reviews
· 9 years ago
Wings were excellent. Pizza was delicious. Service was great. We will definitely go back
P
Pat
10 Ratings
5 Reviews
· 9 years ago
Every pizza we had was awesome. Pulled pork, margarita, truffle and popeye... unbelievable. Don't think of this as a pizza dinner. Think of this as a nice dinner out. Appetizers were great... Dessert even better. Staff was fantastic!You'll be hooked.
B
BEATRICE
2 Ratings
1 Reviews
· 9 years ago
We really enjoy eating here. The food is very good. The specialty pies are creative. The servers are very attentive.
L
Laura
1 Ratings
1 Reviews
· 9 years ago
Prices are more than fair, food was excellent and an interesting menu. Classier than your average pizza place - reminded me of Manhattan. French press coffee-who would have thought in Riverdale, NJ? The service was actually superior
C
Christine
24 Ratings
13 Reviews
· 9 years ago
BYOB restaurant. The caprese salad & Apple dessert pies were delicious! Service was also very good.